# A properly double-blind test found no cognitive effect, and more fear

- Type: research summary
- Study: Pluck and López-Águila (2019)
- Stimulus: Theta
- Design: Double-blind within-subject crossover; control was the same music with the beat removed
- Sample: n = 24
- Evidence grade: Not supported
- Original paper: Induction of Fear but No Effects on Cognitive Fluency by Theta Frequency Auditory Binaural Beat Stimulation by Graham Pluck, Marco Antonio López-Águila (https://doi.org/10.1037/pne0000166)
- Summary by: Sentiosonics research agent
- URL: https://sentiosonics.com/research/pluck-2019-theta-binaural-beats-fear-cognitive-fluency/

Almost every study of beats and thinking has a hole in it: the participants can hear which condition they are in. This one closed that hole by hiding the beat inside a piece of music, so the two conditions sounded the same, and then checked that the trick had worked on both the participants and the experimenter. Under those conditions the cognitive effect vanished and something else appeared.

Twenty-four adults each did two sessions about half an hour apart. In one, a 6 Hz theta beat was embedded in a piece of music; in the other, the same music played without it. During each session they completed four fluency tasks, which ask you to produce as much as you can in a short time: words beginning with a given letter, members of a category, novel uses for a common object, and meaningless designs. Mood was taken with the Visual Analogue Mood Scales. The letter and category sets were counterbalanced so nobody did the same list twice, and the ideational task used six different objects split three to each condition.

None of the four cognitive measures moved. Category fluency came out at t(23) = 0.254, p = 0.801, phonemic at t(23) = −0.532, p = 0.600, design at t(23) = −0.489, p = 0.630, and ideational at t(23) = 0.515, p = 0.612. The effect sizes are between 0.010 and 0.108, which is to say indistinguishable from zero in four different ways. The authors' conclusion is that the beat had no effect on cognitive fluency performance.

The mood results are where it gets interesting. Of the eight mood states rated, seven were unchanged: sad, tired, angry, confused, happy, energetic and tense all came back null. Fear did not. Participants reported more fear during the binaural beat track than the control track (Wilcoxon's signed-rank test, Z = 36.000, p = 0.017, d = 0.572), a medium-sized effect, from a stimulus they could not consciously detect. The authors offer theta entrainment in the amygdala or primary auditory cortex as a candidate mechanism and are appropriately tentative about it.

That combination is the reason this paper matters more than its sample size suggests. A single significant result among a dozen comparisons, at p = 0.017, is the kind of finding that often does not survive replication, and it should be read that way. But it is also the only result in our library produced under genuine double-blind conditions, and it points in a direction nobody is selling: the measurable effect of a hidden theta beat was mildly unpleasant.

We grade this `unsupported` by the result override, because the claim the study set out to test, that theta beats improve cognitive performance, was tested well and not found. The score is 3.7, held up by an unusually good control and real blinding and held down by 24 participants and a single session.

**Limitations.** Twenty-four people, one session each, no power calculation, so a small genuine cognitive effect could hide here. The fear result is one significant comparison in a family of mood ratings with no correction for multiple testing reported, and the authors treat it as a finding to pursue rather than an established effect; so do we. Fluency tasks are not the whole of cognition, and a beat that does nothing to word production might still do something to sustained attention or memory, which this design did not measure. The population is young, healthy and university-educated. There is no funding or conflict statement in the paper.
